11.33 Evaluating Counterarguments and Limitations Worksheet

A research brief claims that switching street parking to dynamic pricing reduces cruising for spots. It acknowledges a counterargument that drivers may instead circle nearby blocks, shifting congestion. The brief responds by citing sensors showing fewer cars on the priced blocks. It does not measure traffic on adjacent streets, and it collected sensor data only during weekdays, not on event nights.

A legal commentary argues that requiring body-worn cameras for all courtroom proceedings increases transparency. It acknowledges a counterargument that cameras could chill witness testimony. The author responds that judges can seal recordings in sensitive cases. The commentary does not explain who decides what counts as 'sensitive,' how often sealing would occur, or how the public would know when sealing is overused.

An education policy article argues that banning zeroes for missing work increases graduation rates. It acknowledges a counterargument that grades may inflate without real learning gains. The author responds by citing higher course pass rates. The article does not report performance on external assessments, does not analyze whether assignments were later completed, and does not examine whether students in later courses struggled more.